Terzo settore senza frontiere – 5. Social Enterprise Corporations: Concept, Benefits, And Safeguards

[Il testo riproduce la relazione svolta dall’autore il 19 novembre 2026 al Convegno internazionale “Corporate Purpose in Reality. International and Comparative Perspectives Conference” – Melbourne Law School and Online]

1. Introduction

Any discussion regarding the purpose of shareholder corporations—and specifically whether a shareholder corporation can pursue a non-profit goal, or even more specifically, a social utility purpose—must inevitably be rooted in the legal framework in which that discussion takes place, although comparative analysis among legal systems is essential, including for legislative and rule-making purposes.

For example, in Italy, unlike in jurisdictions where a corporation may be formed for any lawful purpose, corporations are legally defined by the goal of distributing profits to their shareholders, as set forth in Article 2247 of the Italian Civil Code. This might not prevent a corporation from including a non-distribution constraint or a commitment to benefit society and the community in its articles of incorporation. Yet, these would remain purely contractual provisions, subject to future amendment by the corporation itself. In other words, the matter would be left entirely to private ordering, with statutory law playing no binding role.

This is one of the primary reasons why the Italian legislature introduced specific statutory models for corporations that pursue common-benefit goals alongside profit—known as “società benefit”, or Benefit Corporations—or, in the complete absence of a profit motive, exclusively civic, solidarity-based, and socially useful purposes—known as “società imprese sociali”, or corporate social enterprises.

I will not be focusing today on the first model, the Benefit Corporation.

Instead, my presentation will concentrate on the second model: corporate social enterprises. Compared to standard business corporations, these are atypical entities precisely because of the exclusive social purpose they pursue, rather than the economic benefit of their shareholders. At the legislative level, this is also recognized by the fact that corporate social enterprises automatically fall under the legal category of “Third Sector Entities”, as provided for by the Italian Code of the Third Sector of 2017. Third Sector Entities are the Italian equivalent of the “public benefit organizations” that nearly all national legal systems recognize and regulate under various names—sometimes purely for tax purposes (“tax-exempt organizations”), and other times, as in Italy, also through substantive private law. It must be pointed out, however, that in other countries social enterprises are not automatically recognized by law as public benefit organizations, or at least not all social enterprises are so recognized.

2. Social enterprise legal status

First and foremost, it must be clarified that a corporate social enterprise does not constitute a distinct legal type of entity. In fact, according to Italian Law No. 112/2017, “social enterprise” is a legal status—or legal qualification or certification—that any legal entity, including a shareholder corporation, that meets the statutory requirements can acquire. A social enterprise can retain this status over time only if it complies with the ongoing rules on conduct, disclosure, transparency, and governance imposed on all social enterprises. I will come back on these rules later on in this presentation. Social enterprise is a status that an entity can voluntarily acquire, and later lose—either by choice or by order of the supervisory authority—simply by registering in, or being removed from, a dedicated section of the Italian Register of enterprises.

It should also be emphasized that this status is not limited to shareholder corporations. As stated, the status can in fact be acquired by other legal entities, such as partnerships and cooperatives, as well as by associations, foundations, consortia, and so on. In other words, an entity’s legal form of incorporation is irrelevant to acquiring the social enterprise status. Consequently, depending on the founders’ choice, we can have social enterprises established and operating in the legal form of a foundation, a shareholder corporation, a cooperative, and so on. Accordingly, rather than a “corporation social enterprise”, one may also speak of “a social enterprise in the corporate form”.

Finally, it is worth noting that in the past, Italy recognized social enterprises exclusively in the cooperative form. To be more precise, the Italian legislature had created a dedicated subtype of cooperative for this purpose: the “social cooperative” (cooperativa sociale), governed by Law No. 381 of 1991. Thus, the statutory evolution has moved toward expanding the range of admissible legal forms for social enterprises—a shift made possible precisely by conceiving “social enterprise” as a legal status instead of a specific entity type or subtype. Social enterprise as a legal status was the technical device that allowed the multiplication of the available legal forms of social enterprise.

In my opinion, legislation based on social enterprise as a legal status, qualification, or certification, offers several advantages over a system where a social enterprise is a specific type or subtype of legal entity. These potential benefits, increasingly recognized by legal scholars, have driven the success of this legislative model, which is ever more adopted by national legislators.

One of the main benefits is how easily an existing legal entity can become a social enterprise. To qualify as a social enterprise, an entity does not need to dissolve and reincorporate, nor undergo a formal conversion (namely, a change of the legal form). Instead, it can simply amend its articles of association to meet the statutory requirements of a social enterprise and then apply for registration in the dedicated section of the Register of enterprises.

In the same way, and for the same reasons, it is much easier for a social enterprise to give up its status when it no longer wishes to maintain it. The entity in question simply needs to cancel its registration in the dedicated section of the Register of enterprises and change its article of association (the term “social enterprise” is protected by law and cannot be used by entities that are not registered social enterprises). However, as we will discuss shortly, losing this status triggers a duty to transfer its assets on a disinterested basis (to other social enterprises or third sector organizations), which acts as a strong exit barrier to reinforce and protect the social mission of social enterprises and avoid the exploitation of this legal status.

Finally, status-based legislation on social enterprise makes it easier for the competent public authority to sanction non-compliance with the rules of engagement—such as those on governance and transparency—, namely the rules whose respect is necessary to maintain the status. If and when the supervisory authority finds irregularities, it may simply suspend, where provided by law, or revoke the status. As a result, the entity is temporarily or permanently barred from enjoying the benefits tied to social enterprise status.

However, as has emerged from my previous words and in my previous work on the subject, the most significant advantage of this model is that—while ensuring a common identity for all social enterprises—it allows each organization to choose the legal form under which it prefers to operate, rather than imposing on potential social entrepreneurs the cooperative form, the corporate form, or any other specific legal structure. Having multiple legal forms available enables a social enterprise to tailor its structure to its specific circumstances. For instance, it can adapt to the nature of its founders or members—whether they are workers, investors, or non-profit organizations. It can also reflect the cultural or historical tradition in which social enterprise is rooted, such as that of associations or cooperatives, as well as the nature of its business, whether labor-intensive or capital-intensive. It is very significant that researchers around the world are now starting to explore the reasons behind the choice of the legal form for social enterprise, and that these studies have identified many understandable reasons, legal and non-legal, such as the capacity of a legal form to legitimate the social enterprise to the general public; a need which would not (or would be to a lesser extent) be satisfied under legislation that restricts the available legal forms of social enterprise, as happens in some countries, which for example provide only for the shareholder corporation social enterprise or the cooperative social enterprise.

3. Shareholder corporation social enterprises: Main characteristics, constraints and obligations

In a legal system like Italy’s, where “social enterprise” is a legal status that can be acquired by entities organized under various legal forms, a social enterprise can also take the form of a corporation. So, what kind of corporation is a corporate social enterprise? It is a corporation characterized by a specific social (not merely non-profit) purpose, subject to a set of statutory constraints and obligations, as well as specific forms of external public oversight.

Like all other social enterprises, a corporate social enterprise cannot operate for profit. Instead, it must pursue civic, solidarity-based, and socially useful goals on a not-for-profit basis, primarily by carrying out activities of general interest.

Therefore, the defining features of a corporate social enterprise’s purpose are essentially two:

  • First, carrying out activities of general interest as its primary focus, such as the provision of social services, health services, socio-health services, education, instruction, and professional training. There is a long list of general-interest activities in the law that an entity must select—one or more—to obtain the status of social enterprise. Activities “other” than those of general interest may be conducted by a social enterprise, but only insofar as they are secondary and instrumental relative to the general-interest activities (under Article 6 of the Third Sector Code and Ministerial Decree no. 107/2021).
  • Second, the obligation to reinvest all business profits. Rather than to a profit non-distribution constraint, a social enterprise is more precisely subject to a true “asset lock”, which applies not only during its lifetime, but also at the end of its existence or upon losing its qualification as a social enterprise (which is to say, upon de-registration). It is, however, permitted to distribute dividends to shareholders on the equity capital held, subject to very strict limits: no more than 50% of annual net profits may be distributed (provided there are no prior losses to cover), and each shareholder cannot receive more than a certain percentage of their paid-in capital—currently no more than 6%. From the perspective of financial rights, equity capital is therefore treated much like debt capital, offering a financial return that is conditional on the corporation’s performance, capped, and left to the discretion of the social enterprise’s board of directors.
  • Furthermore, this asset lock also operates if a shareholder exits the corporation—in which case they are entitled only to the reimbursement of their paid-in capital and nothing more—as well as upon the dissolution of the entity or its removal from the “social enterprises” section of the Register of enterprises. In all these scenarios, the remaining assets must be transferred free of charge to other social enterprises or third-sector entities that have been active for at least three years.

Turning to the statutory constraints and obligations, the most relevant ones for today’s discussion are:

  • The prohibition on corporate social enterprises being controlled by public bodies, for-profit corporations, or a single individual. This rule exists to prevent a social enterprise from effectively becoming a mere vehicle to indirectly pursue goals other than its own solidarity-based mission.
  • The obligation for corporate social enterprises to prepare—following guidelines issued by the relevant Ministry—and make public, by filing it with the Register of enterprises, a social impact report (bilancio sociale) documenting which social goals have been pursued and how.
  • The obligation for corporate social enterprises to always appoint an internal supervisory body tasked with verifying not only compliance with the law and the proper preparation of financial statements, but also, specifically, the accurate drafting of the social impact report and the fulfillment of the social mission.
  • The obligation to involve and engage various stakeholders in the governance—first and foremost workers and beneficiaries—through information, consultation, and, in larger corporate social enterprises, even direct representation on both the board of directors and the internal supervisory body.
  • Civil liability of directors and general managers for damages caused through negligence not only to the corporation, its shareholders, and its creditors, but also to third parties—who may therefore include the potential beneficiaries of the social enterprise’s activities.
  • The requirement to obtain prior authorization from the Ministry in order to carry out valid extraordinary transactions such as conversions, mergers, spin-offs, or transfers of a business or business unit.
  • Subjection to specific external inspections carried out annually by the competent Ministry or by a representative association to which the social enterprise belongs.

Through all these mechanisms, Italian law seeks to safeguard the social enterprise’s mission—especially when it takes the corporate form, where the risks of potential mission drift are greater, given the shareholder nature of the enterprise’s constituency. What matters here is the coexistence of all these tools, which vary in nature. On the other hand, they translate into compliance burdens that must be offset by incentives if social enterprises are to thrive. And indeed, Italian law achieves this through various measures, not solely tax-related. Social enterprises do not pay corporate income tax on reinvested profits and enjoy additional benefits, including in their relationships with donors and public bodies.

4. Social enterprises in the shareholder corporate form: Potential benefits

Choosing the corporate form can naturally be driven by the desire to capture all the advantages generally associated with this legal structure. This includes a clear and comprehensive legal framework—compared to alternative forms of social enterprise, such as associations and foundations—and a governance model based on the capital held rather than the democratic principle “one member, one vote”, which characterizes alternative forms of social enterprise, such as cooperatives and associations.

Are there other specific benefits associated with using the corporate form for a social enterprise? The answer is undoubtedly yes.

One of them is a greater ability to attract equity capital—although, of course, the asset lock and the strict caps on the returns suggest that corporate social enterprises will mainly attract “patient” capital from non-speculative or institutional investors focused on the promotion of social enterprises. In Italy, there are dedicated funds for the development of social enterprises set up by representative organizations or other third-sector entities.

Second, given that corporate social enterprises can be controlled even by a single entity, there is the opportunity to establish instrumental social enterprises owned by other third-sector organizations, religious bodies, or non-profits. In fact, this scenario is already playing out in Italy. For example, several philanthropic foundations have set up fully owned corporate social enterprises to manage specific general-interest services. The same is happening among religious organizations, which, rather than managing general-interest services directly in-house, outsource them to a corporate social enterprise they have established and fully own. This generates interesting groups of third sector and non-profit entities.

A further innovative use of corporate social enterprises is emerging in Italy in the field of public–third-sector partnerships. Some municipalities entrust social services to mixed public–private corporate social enterprises, where in turn the private side consists of social enterprises and other third-sector entities. Moreover, these corporations are controlled by the private third-sector shareholders, because, as mentioned earlier, public bodies are prohibited from controlling social enterprises. Therefore, the corporate social enterprise also enables social innovation in the area of institutionalized public-private partnerships.

5. Conclusions

I am now coming to the conclusions.

First, I am convinced that specific laws on social enterprises—and more broadly on corporations that pursue social goals, even if only in part—are necessary to encourage the spread of organizational models that benefit society as a whole. In this sense, the law performs an essential function: it signals the commitment to pursuing the common good, thereby fostering trust in social enterprises while at the same time protecting the trust placed in them. In my view, this conclusion holds true even in legal systems that, unlike the Italian one, do not tie corporations strictly to a profit-making purpose or to shareholder wealth maximization.

Second, it seems increasingly clear to me that status-based legislation on social enterprises is the most effective approach, precisely because it allows for a wide variety of legal forms for social enterprises, not just the corporate form. The pluralism of legal forms and organizational models is a value in itself, in addition to being instrumental to the growth of social enterprises in a given country—as the evolving numbers in Italy clearly show, with a growing number of corporate social enterprises alongside social cooperatives (which previously accounted for 97% of the total but are now declining).

Third, any legislation on social enterprises must take care to safeguard their mission and protect their identity from the risk of abuse. Such abuse would harm not only the beneficiaries, donors, and stakeholders of an individual social enterprise, but social enterprises more broadly as an entire sector—because the higher the trust placed in a category of entities, the more that trust becomes a shared asset, meaning that any harm spreads across the whole system and causes irreparable reputational damage. This requires adequate and effective rules and oversight.

At the same time, because social enterprises are subject to constraints, obligations, and controls that other businesses do not face, they must receive incentives that offset these burdens, also in light of the social goals they pursue. Without statutory incentives, including a tailored tax regime, social enterprises can hardly thrive. Very significant in this regard is the fact that the European Commission has recently found the preferential tax treatment of Italian social enterprises—specifically, the full tax exemption on reinvested profits—to be fully compatible with EU competition law. This is because social enterprises do not receive tax breaks, but rather a tax treatment suited to their specific legal nature. This marks a new way of thinking, one that finally recognizes the diversity among businesses enterprises based on the different purposes they pursue.

Thank you very much for your kind attention.

TUTTI I DIRITTI RISERVATI. È vietato qualsiasi utilizzo, totale o parziale, del presente documento per scopi commerciali, senza previa autorizzazione scritta di Terzjus.
Torna in alto

Ricevi aggiornamenti,
news e approfondimenti sulle attività di Terzjus